Wal-Mart Manufactures Fake Public Support in Chicago

Wal-Mart is up to its old tricks again.

Ever since I decided to stop shopping there more than five years ago, I've kept track of Wal-Mart's gaffes and legal blunders. I've also given Wal-Mart credit for being a leader in making its buildings more energy efficient and encouraging vendors to use less packaging.

When I tuned in to Twitter today, several people had pointed out that apparently, Wal-Mart has learned nothing from its first fake foray into social media.

Chicago is a difficult market to break into for a retailer. That is a fact. Wal-Mart's frustration with not being able to waltz in and build one of its mega stores without resistance from organized labor and neighborhood groups is without a doubt frustrating.

But under NO circumstances should a company ever be tempted to use "fake" grassroots support. That is exactly what Wal-Mart attempted to do, with the help of the Chicago Chamber of Commerce and its public relations firm, Serafin and Associates.

As a powerful and influential member of the Chicago Chamber, Wal-Mart has shown that it is learning how to play the game in local markets in which it's trying to gain influence. Instead of just flying into town with its gigantic legal team and blanketing the airwaves with branding ads, it's trying to gain influence in some very traditional ways. Joining the Chamber of Commerce, as a tactic,  could not have been more old school.

Wal Mart (hiding behind the Chamber banner) has launched a fake grassroots Web site called, "Our Community, Your Choice" to highlight the benefits of having a Wal-Mart in the community. The site is incredibly "on message" with Wal-Mart's normal talking points it uses when moving in to a community.

According to the site, Wal-Mart would bring jobs and healthier food choices to residents of the South and West sides. Ok, I'll buy that (albeit low wage jobs with no health insurance for most employees). This is where it goes fishy, though. The site says the new Wal Mart will attract more shoppers to other businesses! What planet are they on? It's pretty well documented that Wal-Mart has a tremendously negative effect on adjacent businesses when it moves into an area.

Then it gets even better. The Chicagoist tracked down the IP address of the commenters defending Wal- Mart on its site. You guessed it! Paid astroturfers (read: fake grassroots). Once they figured out the true origins of the campaign and requested an interview, Wal-Mart went into hibernation and stopped answering phone calls and emails regarding the issue.

I wonder when big companies and chambers will stop trying to get their message out by using disingenuous methods. They must know by now that transparency and honesty are the cornerstones of the social media universe. Serafin most certainly should have known. The Chicago Chamber of Commerce is basically laundering Wal-Mart's money by putting its name on the site. Wal-Mart should have just put up its own site and taken responsibility for its own position.

The Chamber and Wal-Mart both have the right and the responsibility to get their side of the story out to the residents of Chicago. There are undoubtedly benefits to Wal-Mart to have a presence in this lucrative market, and benefits to the community to have Wal-Mart there. But to manufacture fake support in this manner is simply disingenuous and does not have a place in the social media sphere.

The only people who have not weighed in are the citizens of Chicago. If you are one of them, please leave a comment and share your feelings about Wal-Mart trying this tactic. Does it move you to action?

Comments

[Deb]

I lived in Chicago for 30 years. My friends who still live there "oh HELL no".

That sums it up for me.